Regulation A Explained: Tier 1 Up to $20 Million, Tier 2 Up to $75 Million — and the Qualification That Comes First

Date:

By Jean-Francois Amyot

Standfirst: Regulation A is the larger of the two public exempt offerings in U.S. securities law: up to $20 million under Tier 1 and up to $75 million under Tier 2, sold to the general public without a full registration statement. In exchange, the company files an offering statement, waits for the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to qualify it before a single sale, and — under Tier 2 — accepts audited financial statements and continuing reports. It is often called a “mini-IPO.” The nickname is accurate in one respect only: like an IPO, it is a public offering with a regulator’s review in the middle of it.

Where Regulation A sits

Most of the exemptions in this series are private in practice. Regulation D offerings are built around accredited investors and existing relationships. Regulation Crowdfunding, covered here on November 17, opens the door to the general public but caps the raise at $5 million in a 12-month period and routes every sale through one registered intermediary.

Regulation A — expanded by Title IV of the JOBS Act and often called Regulation A+ — is the step above that. It comes from Securities Act Section 3(b)(2), and it lets an eligible company offer and sell securities to the public, accredited and non-accredited investors alike, through a process the SEC itself describes as similar to, but less extensive than, a registered offering. There is no single-portal rule as in Regulation Crowdfunding. What there is, instead, is a filing, a review, and a gate: no sales until the offering statement is qualified.

That gate is the feature founders most often underestimate, and it shapes everything else in this article.

Two tiers, two bargains

An issuer elects one tier for its offering, and the election is a genuine trade-off, not a formality.

Tier 1 permits offerings of up to $20 million in a 12-month period, including no more than $6 million on behalf of selling securityholders who are affiliates of the issuer. Tier 1 carries the lighter federal load: no audited financial statements are required unless the issuer has already prepared them for other purposes, there are no federal investment limits on purchasers, and after the offering the issuer’s only federal filing is an exit report. The catch is below the federal level, and it is a large one: a Tier 1 issuer must also register or qualify its offering — or find an exemption — in every state where it offers or sells. A national Tier 1 campaign therefore means state-by-state review on top of SEC qualification, which is why a coordinated state review program exists to process multi-state Tier 1 offerings.

Tier 2 permits offerings of up to $75 million in a 12-month period, including no more than $22.5 million on behalf of selling securityholders who are affiliates. In exchange for the higher ceiling, Tier 2 imposes the heavier discipline: audited financial statements in the offering circular, investment limits for non-accredited purchasers, and ongoing reporting for as long as the reporting obligation lasts. What Tier 2 removes is the state layer: a Tier 2 issuer is not required to register or qualify the offering with state securities regulators, although states keep their enforcement and antifraud authority, and notice filings and state fees may still apply.

Across both tiers, one further cap applies to resales inside the offering itself: sales by all selling securityholders together may not exceed 30 percent of the aggregate offering price in the issuer’s first Regulation A offering and in any Regulation A offerings qualified within the following 12 months. Regulation A is primarily a capital-raising tool for the company, not an early exit mechanism for insiders, and the arithmetic enforces that.

Who may use it — and who may not

Regulation A is available only to companies organized in, and with their principal place of business in, the United States or Canada. Beyond geography, the SEC’s guidance lists issuers that cannot use it, including companies registered or required to be registered under the Investment Company Act and business development companies; development-stage companies with no specific business plan, or whose stated plan is to merge with or acquire an unidentified company; issuers of fractional undivided interests in oil, gas or similar mineral rights; issuers that failed to file the ongoing reports Regulation A or the Exchange Act required of them during the two years before filing a new offering statement; issuers subject to a Commission order denying, suspending or revoking registration of a class of securities under Exchange Act Section 12(j) entered within the previous five years; and issuers disqualified under Regulation A’s “bad actor” rule, Rule 262, which looks to specified convictions, court orders and regulatory sanctions involving the issuer and covered persons such as directors, officers, 20-percent owners and compensated solicitors.

The eligible securities are also a defined list — equity and debt securities, warrants, and securities convertible or exchangeable into equity, among others — and asset-backed securities are excluded from it.

Read together, the pattern is the same one Regulation Crowdfunding shows: the exemption is aimed at operating companies, in the U.S. and Canada, raising money for an identified business, with a compliance history that does not disqualify them. A company that has already let its reporting lapse has, by that fact alone, closed this door until the record is repaired.

Form 1-A: the offering statement

Every Regulation A offering begins with an offering statement on Form 1-A, filed electronically on EDGAR. Form 1-A has three parts: Part I, a structured notice giving basic information about the issuer and the offering, including certifications of eligibility and bad-actor status; Part II, the offering circular — the disclosure document investors actually read — together with the financial statements; and Part III, the exhibits, including the issuer’s charter documents, the instrument defining the securityholders’ rights, the subscription agreement, material contracts, a legality opinion, and any testing-the-waters materials.

The financial statements cover the two previous fiscal years, or the shorter period the issuer has existed, and must be current: the most recent balance sheet may not be older than nine months at submission, filing or qualification. The tier election decides their scrutiny. Tier 1 statements need not be audited unless audited statements already exist. Tier 2 statements must be audited, under either AICPA or PCAOB standards.

An issuer that has never sold securities under a qualified Regulation A offering statement or an effective registration statement may submit a draft offering statement for non-public staff review first — but the confidentiality is temporary: the draft, its amendments and the related staff correspondence must all be publicly filed on EDGAR at least 21 calendar days before qualification.

Qualification is not a formality

Here is the sentence that separates Regulation A from every filing-and-go exemption: issuers are only permitted to begin selling securities once the offering statement has been qualified by the Commission. The Division of Corporation Finance issues a notice of qualification, which the SEC’s guidance describes as analogous to a notice of effectiveness in a registered offering.

That means a Regulation A timeline is not in the issuer’s control. The staff may review, comment and require amendments, and the offering cannot launch on the founder’s schedule — it launches when the qualification arrives. Founders budgeting a Regulation A raise should treat the review period the way they would treat any other regulatory dependency: real, variable, and impossible to promise to investors in advance. A company that needs money in 30 days does not have a Regulation A problem; it has chosen the wrong exemption for its timeline.

Testing the waters — with legends

Regulation A does permit an issuer to “test the waters”: to solicit indications of interest from the general public before or after the offering statement is filed, in order to learn whether a contemplated offering has an audience before paying the full cost of preparing one. The permission is conditional. Solicitation materials must carry the legends the rules require — that no money is being solicited or will be accepted, that no offer can be accepted until qualification, and that an indication of interest is no commitment — and after the offering statement is publicly filed, the materials must be preceded or accompanied by the preliminary offering circular, or tell investors where and how to get it. The materials themselves are filed as an exhibit to Form 1-A.

Testing the waters gauges interest. It does not take money, it does not create commitments, and it does not shorten the qualification gate by a day.

Who may invest, and how much

In a Tier 1 offering, there are no federal investment limitations: any member of the public may invest, in any amount, subject to the state law that governs the offering where they are.

Tier 2 is different. Unless the securities will be listed on a national securities exchange upon qualification, a purchaser who is not an accredited investor may buy no more than 10 percent of the greater of annual income or net worth, for a natural person, or 10 percent of the greater of annual revenue or net assets, for an entity. Accredited investors face no such limit, and neither does any purchaser where the securities will be exchange-listed on qualification.

The logic mirrors Regulation Crowdfunding’s caps at a larger scale: public access to early-stage risk is deliberate, and so is a ceiling on how much of that risk one non-accredited household can take in a single offering.

After qualification: the reporting tail

Tier 1’s tail is short. The issuer files an exit report on Form 1-Z no later than 30 calendar days after the offering terminates or completes, reporting the securities sold and updating certain issuer information. That is the end of its Regulation A reporting.

Tier 2’s tail is a reporting regime. A Tier 2 issuer files an annual report on Form 1-K within 120 calendar days of its fiscal year end, with updated business disclosure and two years of audited financial statements; a semiannual report on Form 1-SA within 90 calendar days after the first six months of the fiscal year; and current reports on Form 1-U within four business days of specified events, including fundamental changes, bankruptcy or receivership, a change of certifying accountant, a change in control, and the departure of a principal executive, financial or accounting officer. An exit report on Form 1-Z is also required in certain circumstances, and a Tier 2 issuer that has kept its reports current and whose securities are held of record by fewer than 300 persons, with no ongoing offering, may suspend the obligation by filing that form.

One further Tier 2 benefit is worth naming, because it explains why some issuers accept the reporting tail willingly: securities issued in a Tier 2 offering are conditionally exempt from the mandatory Exchange Act Section 12(g) registration that a widely held class of equity would otherwise trigger, for so long as the issuer stays current in its Regulation A reports and uses a registered transfer agent, subject to size limits. In plain terms, a Tier 2 issuer can have a broad public shareholder base without automatically becoming a full Exchange Act reporting company — provided it keeps reporting under Regulation A instead.

Choosing between the tiers — and between exemptions

The tier question usually answers itself once three facts are on the table. How much must be raised: above $20 million, only Tier 2 is available. Where will investors be: a genuinely national offering makes Tier 1’s state-by-state qualification a serious cost and delay, while a small, local Tier 1 offering may bear it comfortably. And can the company carry Tier 2’s discipline: audited statements now, and annual, semiannual and current reporting afterward. An issuer that cannot produce audited financial statements is not ready for Tier 2, whatever its target amount.

The wider comparison belongs in the same conversation. Regulation Crowdfunding trades a $5 million ceiling for a portal-based process with no SEC qualification review. Regulation D trades public access for speed and no dollar ceiling, within its own investor and solicitation rules. Regulation A trades time — a filed offering statement and a qualification that arrives on the regulator’s schedule — for the right to sell larger amounts to the general public. None of the three is “easier” in the abstract. Each is a different exchange of money, audience, disclosure and time, and the founder’s job is to pick the exchange that matches the raise actually being attempted.

Regulation A rewards companies that behave like public companies before they are required to: audited numbers, a disclosure document that can survive staff review, and reporting that continues after the celebration. That is not a defect in the exemption. It is the exemption working as designed — public money, at a meaningful scale, in return for public-company habits in miniature.

This article is education, not legal or investment advice. Whether a company is eligible for Regulation A, which tier fits, and how qualification, investment limits and ongoing reporting apply turn on the regulation’s rules and the company’s specific facts. Founders and investors should confirm their position with qualified securities counsel in every jurisdiction involved — in Canada, that includes provincial regulators such as Quebec’s Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) and the Ontario Securities Commission alongside U.S. federal law where U.S. securities or investors are involved.

Jean-Francois Amyot is an independent journalist and author of The Art of War Remastered.

Jean-Francois Amyot
Jean-Francois Amyothttps://hollingerpost.com
Jean-Francois Amyot is an independent journalist and author. He writes on capital markets, cryptocurrency, blockchain, startups, financing and securities regulation (SEC, AMF, OSC), plus community stories on youth sport and helping young people stay in the game. Author of The Art of War Remastered and The World of Cryptocurrencies. Contact: jfamyot@gmail.com

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

Markets: Nasdaq Falls 5.3 Per Cent as the S&P 500 and the Dow Enter Correction in an AI-Led Rout

By Jean-Francois Amyot Standfirst: Wall Street closed its worst week...

Capital Markets Tribunal Sets Disclosure and Witness Deadlines in Ontario Securities Commission v Furtak

Ontario's Capital Markets Tribunal has issued an order in...

SEC Files Settled Charges Against Jose A. Gamez Over Alleged Misappropriation From Elderly Clients

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has filed settled...

Capital Markets Tribunal Schedules December 9 Case Management Hearing in the Emerge Canada Case

Ontario's Capital Markets Tribunal has scheduled a case management...