Paid to Promote? Disclose It: The One Rule That Separates Investor Relations From Touting

Date:

By Jean-Francois Amyot

Standfirst: Paying for publicity about a stock is not, by itself, illegal. Hiding the payment is. One sentence in the U.S. Securities Act of 1933 — Section 17(b), the anti-touting provision — requires anyone who publicizes a security for pay from an issuer, an underwriter or a dealer to fully disclose that they were paid and how much. It is the simplest rule in promotion, and the one most often broken.

The rule, in its own words

Section 17(b) of the Securities Act, codified at 15 U.S.C. 77q(b), makes it unlawful for any person, using interstate commerce or the mails, to “publish, give publicity to, or circulate any notice, circular, advertisement, newspaper, article, letter, investment service, or communication which, though not purporting to offer a security for sale, describes such security for a consideration received or to be received, directly or indirectly, from an issuer, underwriter, or dealer, without fully disclosing the receipt, whether past or prospective, of such consideration and the amount thereof.”

Read that slowly, because every phrase does work.

First, the communication does not have to offer the security for sale. An article, a newsletter, a video, a social-media post — anything that describes a security can fall inside the provision. “I wasn’t selling anything, I was just writing about the company” is not a defence the statute recognizes.

Second, the consideration can be past or prospective, direct or indirect. Payment that has not arrived yet counts. Payment routed through a communications firm, a promoter, or another intermediary counts. And consideration is not limited to cash: shares, options, warrants or anything else of value given for coverage are payment in substance, whatever the contract calls them.

Third — and this is where most failures happen — disclosure must be full, and it must include the amount. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s investor guidance on investment newsletters puts the standard in plain terms: when newsletters receive payment for touting, the securities laws require them to disclose specifically who paid them, the amount, and the type of payment — cash, stock, or some other thing of value. The SEC tells investors to be suspicious of newsletters that do not specifically disclose those three items, and to think twice about disclosures buried in tiny, hard-to-read type.

A line that says a writer “may have been compensated” does not state an amount. A generic disclaimer on a separate web page does not tell the reader of this article what this article cost, or who paid for it. The disclosure belongs in the communication itself, where the reader will actually see it.

What the rule does not do

Section 17(b) does not ban promotion. The SEC’s own investor material makes the point directly: touting is not illegal as long as the promoter discloses who paid, how much, and in what form. A disclosed paid article is lawful — but it should be read for what it is, which is an advertisement, not independent research.

Disclosure is also a floor, not a shield. A promoter who discloses payment and then publishes statements that are false or misleading, or leaves out material facts, is still exposed under the securities laws’ anti-fraud provisions. Putting the payment in the fine print does not launder the claims in the headline. The honest sequence is both: say you were paid, and say only what is true and complete.

Why this rule exists: the reader cannot weigh what they cannot see

The reason for the rule is not paperwork. A reader evaluates a bullish article differently when they know the writer was paid by the company — differently again when they know the writer was paid in shares, whose value rises if the article works, and differently again when they know the writer is free to sell into the buying the article creates. Compensation is material information about the message itself. Hiding it does not merely omit a detail; it changes what the reader believes they are reading, from analysis into advertising dressed as analysis.

The SEC’s November 1, 2017 statement on celebrity-backed initial coin offerings made the same point for the social-media era: endorsements may be unlawful if they do not disclose the nature, source and amount of any compensation paid, directly or indirectly, by the company in exchange for the endorsement, and anyone promoting a virtual token or coin that is a security must disclose the nature, scope and amount of the compensation received. A famous name does not change the analysis. A short post does not shrink the obligation.

What happens when the payment stays hidden

On April 10, 2017, in Press Release 2017-79, the SEC announced enforcement actions against 27 individuals and entities behind what it described as alleged stock promotion schemes that left investors with the impression they were reading independent, unbiased analyses on investing websites while writers were being secretly compensated for touting company stocks. According to the SEC, its investigations found public companies hiring promoters or communications firms to generate publicity, those firms hiring writers, and the resulting articles not disclosing the payments. More than 250 articles, the SEC alleged, specifically included false statements that the writers had not been compensated by the companies they were writing about. The SEC filed fraud charges against three public companies and seven stock promotion or communications firms, as well as two company chief executives, six individuals at the promotion firms, and nine writers.

Note the structure, because it is the standard one: the liability did not stop with the writers. It ran up the chain — to the firms that hired them and the companies that hired the firms. An issuer cannot outsource its way out of this rule by putting a promoter between itself and the keyboard. If a company pays, directly or indirectly, for publicity about its stock, the investing public is entitled to know it, and everyone in the chain should assume the question will eventually be asked of them.

A working test for issuers, promoters and readers

For a company or a promoter preparing any paid communication about a security, four questions cover most of the ground:

  1. Who paid? Name the payer — the issuer, or whoever actually funded the communication — not a vague reference to “third parties.”
  2. How much? State the amount. A dollar figure for cash; the number and kind of securities for share-based pay.
  3. In what form, and for what? Cash, stock, options or warrants, and the period or services the payment covers.
  4. Where does it appear? In the communication itself, prominently — not buried, not in unreadable type, and not only behind a link to a general disclosures page.

For a reader, the test runs in reverse. Before acting on any enthusiastic article, video or post about a small or unfamiliar company, find the disclosure first. If it names the payer, the amount and the form of payment, you are reading an advertisement and can weigh it as one. If it is vague, buried, or missing, the SEC’s advice is the right advice: be skeptical, and independently investigate the company through its own filings before believing a word of the promotion.

The larger point

Legitimate investor relations and unlawful touting can look similar from a distance — both involve telling a company’s story to the market. The difference is not enthusiasm, and it is not production quality. It is disclosure and accuracy: material information given to everyone the same way, and paid advocacy labelled as paid advocacy, in the piece itself, with the amount attached. Companies that build their market presence on that basis have nothing to explain when a regulator, a journalist or an investor asks who paid for the coverage. Companies that hide the payment have usually hidden it because they understood exactly what disclosure would do to the message. That understanding is the offence.

This article is education, not legal or investment advice. How Section 17(b) and the anti-fraud provisions apply to a particular communication turns on its specific facts. Companies and promoters should confirm their disclosure obligations with qualified securities counsel before a campaign runs — not after it is questioned.

Jean-Francois Amyot is an independent journalist and author of The Art of War Remastered.

Jean-Francois Amyot
Jean-Francois Amyothttps://hollingerpost.com
Jean-Francois Amyot is an independent journalist and author. He writes on capital markets, cryptocurrency, blockchain, startups, financing and securities regulation (SEC, AMF, OSC), plus community stories on youth sport and helping young people stay in the game. Author of The Art of War Remastered and The World of Cryptocurrencies. Contact: jfamyot@gmail.com

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

Markets: Securitize Completes Acquisition of River One, Moving From Tokenizing Assets to Financing Them

Standfirst: Securitize Corp. (NYSE: SECZ), the tokenization platform behind...

SEC Enforcement: SEC Charges Eight Entities in Alleged Fake Crypto Asset Trading Platform Scheme Involving More Than $37 Million

By Jean-Francois Amyot Standfirst: The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission...

OSC Enforcement: Capital Markets Tribunal Schedules November 30 Case Management Hearing in the Cloth Case

By Jean-Francois Amyot Standfirst: Ontario's Capital Markets Tribunal has scheduled...

SEC Enforcement: SEC Announces Settlement and Final Judgment Against Carlos Sacanell in Insider Trading Case

By Jean-Francois Amyot Standfirst: The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission...