By Jean-Francois Amyot
Standfirst: A raise is not closed when someone says yes, and it is not closed when money lands in a bank account. It is closed when the documents say who bought what, on what terms, under which exemption, and when — and when the company’s own record matches those documents exactly. Paper first is not bureaucracy. It is the closing itself.
A yes is not a purchase
Every founder knows the moment: an investor listens, nods, and says, “I’m in.” It feels like the end of the hard part. Legally, almost nothing has happened yet.
No security has been described with precision. No price, class, or rights have been fixed. No investor qualification has been recorded. No one has acknowledged the risks, the resale restrictions, or the fact that the investment could be lost. And no record exists that a later investor, auditor, buyer, or regulator could test.
That gap between a verbal yes and a documented purchase is where many small-company problems are born. Months later the founder remembers a friendly conversation. The investor remembers a promise. The documents — if there are any — remember something else. When memories differ, the paper is what gets read.
The term sheet: a map, not the territory
The first document in most raises is the term sheet. Its job is to set out the main commercial terms in one place before longer documents are drafted: what kind of security is being offered, how much is being raised, the price or the way the price will be set, what rights the security carries, and any major conditions the parties expect.
Founders should understand two things about a term sheet. First, it is a negotiating map, not a substitute for the final documents. The details that protect both sides — definitions, conditions, representations, and what happens in specific events — live in the documents that follow, and a short summary can hide a long consequence.
Second, not every line in a term sheet carries the same weight. Some provisions are commonly treated as binding even in an otherwise non-binding summary — confidentiality is a familiar example — while the main investment terms are usually not final until the definitive documents are signed. Which parts bind, and which do not, should be stated on the face of the term sheet itself, not assumed from habit. If a founder cannot say which parts are binding, counsel should answer that question before anyone signs.
Read a term sheet for what will be hard to change later. Valuation is the number people notice. The rights attached to the security, how future rounds may dilute earlier investors, and what consent rights investors receive are the terms people live with.
The subscription documents: where the investor actually buys
If the term sheet is the map, the subscription documents are the purchase. In a typical private offering, an investor signs subscription documents that identify the investor, state the amount and the security being bought, and record the basis on which the investor qualifies for the exemption being used.
That last point is not a formality. Earlier articles in this series explained that an offering’s route depends on who is allowed to invest. The subscription package is where that planning becomes evidence. It is where an investor confirms accredited status where that status is required, acknowledges that the securities are restricted where they are, and confirms that they received the disclosure the offering promised to provide.
Subscription documents also protect the investor. They should make plain what is being bought, what it costs, what rights it does and does not carry, and how and when the purchase becomes final. An investor who is asked to wire money before seeing those terms is not being offered efficiency. They are being asked to buy first and read later.
Companies do not have to accept every subscription. A properly run offering reserves the ability to reject or reduce a subscription — for example, if qualification cannot be established, if accepting it would break the conditions of the exemption, or if the offering is oversubscribed. That right, and how refunds are handled if a subscription is not accepted, belong in the documents before money moves.
Disclosure must match the documents
Paper first also means consistency. The pitch deck, the term sheet, the subscription documents, and any filing made for the offering must tell the same story about the company, the security, the use of proceeds, and the risks.
Where they differ, the difference becomes the story. A deck that describes a use of proceeds the offering documents do not mention, a term sheet that promises rights the final documents narrow, or a social media post that states a return the documents carefully do not promise — each one creates a record that anti-fraud rules will be applied to. Exempt offerings are not exempt from honesty. A statement does not become safe because the offering was private.
This is why experienced founders freeze a single version of the facts before an offering opens, and then make every later document follow it. Updating disclosure when something material changes is not a weakness. Leaving three inconsistent versions in circulation is.
The cap table: the company’s memory
After the subscription documents, the next record is the capitalisation table — the cap table. It lists who owns what: every share issued, every option or warrant outstanding, and every convertible instrument that could become shares later.
A clean cap table is a closing document, not a housekeeping chore for next year. It should be updated as part of the closing itself, so that the day the money arrives, the company’s own record of ownership is complete. Founders who postpone that update discover the cost at the worst moment: in diligence for the next round, a sale, or a dispute, when promises made in emails and side conversations have to be reconciled with a register that was never kept current.
Three habits keep a cap table trustworthy. Record every promise when it is made, not when it is exercised. Keep the signed documents with the table, so every line can be traced to its source. And never let a side letter, a verbal discount, or an informal promise to an adviser live outside the record. If it affects ownership, it belongs on the table.
Money, closing, and the filing that follows
A disciplined closing fixes the mechanics in advance: where funds are sent, whether they are held until a minimum amount or another condition is met where the route requires it, when a subscription is accepted, and when the investor is actually recorded as a holder. “We received the wire” is not the same event as “the purchase closed,” and the documents should say which event does what.
Some routes add a notice filing after sales begin. Under Regulation D, for example, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission requires an issuer to file a Form D notice within 15 days after the first sale of securities in the offering — and the SEC defines that first sale as the date the first investor is irrevocably contractually committed to invest. Form D is a notice, not an approval, and it does not register the offering. But its deadline is counted from a documented event, which is one more reason the subscription date has to be precise rather than remembered.
Resale limits belong in this conversation too. Securities sold in many private placements are restricted securities, and investors should be told, in the documents they sign, that resale may be limited for a period and may require registration or another exemption. Learning that after purchase is a grievance. Reading it before purchase is disclosure.
What investors should ask before they sign
Paper first cuts both ways. Before signing, an investor can reasonably ask for the final or near-final documents, not only a deck; for a clear statement of the rights of the security being bought; for the current cap table or a summary of what will be outstanding after the round; for how their qualification will be recorded; and for what happens to their funds if the offering does not reach its stated minimum or their subscription is not accepted.
A company that answers those questions calmly, in writing, is showing how it will behave after the money arrives. A company that treats documents as an insult to trust is asking for trust on the one subject where trust should be verified.
The handshake still matters — as the start
None of this is an argument against relationships. Most early investment begins with people who believe in a founder, and that belief is real capital. The argument is about order. A handshake is an excellent way to begin a raise. It is a poor way to record one.
Shake hands, then do the paper — term sheet that states what binds and what does not, subscription documents that record who bought what and on what basis, disclosure that matches across every version, a cap table updated at closing, and any notice filing counted from the documented first sale. Founders who work that way are not slower. They are the ones whose next raise starts with records a new investor can trust, instead of apologies for records no one kept.
This article is education, not legal or investment advice. The documents a particular offering requires, and the terms they should contain, turn on the exemption relied on, the jurisdictions involved, and the company’s specific facts. Founders and investors should confirm their position with qualified securities counsel before any sale.
Jean-Francois Amyot is an independent journalist and author of The Art of War Remastered.
