Accredited or Not? Who Is Allowed to Invest, and Why It Changes Everything

Date:

Before a founder can choose how to raise money, one question decides who may even be in the room: is each investor accredited? The answer determines which exemption is available, whether the offering may be advertised, what must be disclosed, and how an investor’s status must be checked — and it has to be answered before the conversation, not after the money arrives.

There is no certificate, and no government stamp

The first surprise for many founders is that “accredited investor” is not a licence anyone issues. No regulator examines an investor, awards a credential, and enters a name on a public list. Under the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) definition, an investor either meets one of the specified criteria at the time of the sale, or does not. The responsibility for making that determination — carefully, and on evidence appropriate to the offering — sits with the company selling the securities.

That makes accredited status a legal test, not a social description. A successful founder, a wealthy-looking neighbour, or a retired executive may or may not meet it. A younger investor who holds the right professional licence may meet it without meeting any wealth test at all. Assumptions based on lifestyle, job title, or confidence are not a determination, and in a later dispute or examination they will not be treated as one.

The individual tests: wealth, income, and professional knowledge

For individuals, the SEC groups the routes to accredited status in three broad families.

The financial criteria are the best known. An individual may qualify with a net worth over $1 million, excluding the primary residence, counted individually or together with a spouse or partner. Or an individual may qualify on income: income over $200,000 individually, or over $300,000 together with a spouse or partner, in each of the prior two years, with a reasonable expectation of reaching the same level in the current year. Note the discipline built into both tests. Net worth is not everything a person owns — the home they live in is taken out of the calculation. Income is not one good year — it must be shown for each of the two prior years, with a reasonable expectation for the present one.

The professional criteria recognise that financial sophistication does not only come from wealth. Investment professionals in good standing who hold the general securities representative licence (Series 7), the investment adviser representative licence (Series 65), or the private securities offerings representative licence (Series 82) may qualify. So may directors, executive officers, or general partners of the company selling the securities. Two narrower routes also exist: a “family client” of a qualifying family office, and, for an investment in a private fund, a “knowledgeable employee” of that fund.

Entities have their own routes. Depending on structure and assets, an entity may qualify if it owns investments in excess of $5 million, if it is one of the listed kinds of entity with assets in excess of $5 million, if all of its equity owners are themselves accredited investors, or if it falls within the categories for registered investment advisers, SEC-registered broker-dealers, and specified financial institutions. An entity formed simply to get around the test is a problem counsel needs to examine, not a workaround a founder should improvise.

Other jurisdictions draw this line in their own way, with their own definitions and thresholds. A raise that touches Canada, for example, is governed province by province — in Quebec by the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) and in Ontario by the Ontario Securities Commission — and a U.S. determination does not travel across the border. Founders raising in more than one country need the test applied, separately, under each system that applies.

Why one investor’s status changes the whole offering

Accredited status matters because exemptions are built around it. Change who is allowed to invest, and the structure, communications, and paperwork of the raise change with it. Regulation D’s Rule 506 — the route behind many U.S. private placements, which the SEC notes can be used to raise an unlimited amount — shows the trade clearly, in its two forms.

Under Rule 506(b), a company may sell to an unlimited number of accredited investors and to up to 35 other purchasers. Those non-accredited purchasers must be sophisticated — alone, or together with a purchaser representative, they must have sufficient knowledge and experience in financial and business matters to evaluate the merits and risks of the investment. In exchange for that limited room for non-accredited buyers, the company gives up reach: it cannot use general solicitation or advertising to market the securities. Including non-accredited investors also raises the disclosure burden, because they must be given disclosure documents generally of the kind used in Regulation A or registered offerings, including financial statements that in some cases must be certified or audited — and any information given to accredited investors must also be made available to them.

Under Rule 506(c), the bargain reverses. A company may broadly solicit and generally advertise the offering — but every investor in the offering must be accredited, with no room for the 35 non-accredited purchasers allowed under Rule 506(b), and the company must take reasonable steps to verify that status. The SEC describes verification as potentially including reviewing documentation such as W-2s, tax returns, bank and brokerage statements, and credit reports. A founder who wants to advertise a raise publicly has therefore chosen, at the same moment, a narrower investor pool and a heavier checking obligation.

The public-facing exemptions tell the same story from the other direction. Regulation Crowdfunding and Regulation A exist precisely to let companies reach investors who are not accredited — and, in return, they impose their own issuer limits, investor limits, intermediary or filing requirements, and ongoing obligations. There is no route in which a company gets a public audience, unlimited non-accredited participation, and light obligations at the same time. Accredited status is the hinge on which that trade turns.

A simple decision tree founders can use before any conversation

First, list who will actually be approached — not who might be interested one day, but the real people, in the real jurisdictions, for this raise. Second, test each person or entity against the definition that applies to them, and record how the test was met. Third, let the answers choose the route: an all-accredited, verified pool points one way; a pool that includes even a small number of non-accredited investors points another, and may rule out advertising the offering altogether. Fourth, set the communications to match the route before anything is posted, pitched publicly, or forwarded — because a message sent to the wrong audience cannot be unsent when counsel reviews it later.

Two cautions belong on the same page. Accredited does not mean an investment is suitable, safe, or likely to succeed; it is a threshold about financial capacity and sophistication, not a judgement about a particular deal. And accredited status does not dilute the anti-fraud rules, which apply to what is said to every investor, accredited or not. Securities bought under Rule 506 are also restricted securities, which under the SEC’s summary cannot be sold for at least six months or a year without registration — a limit investors should understand before they buy, not discover when they want to exit.

The question that protects both sides

Founders sometimes treat the accredited question as gatekeeping, and investors sometimes treat being asked as an insult. It is neither. It is the mechanism by which the law decides how much protective process a particular offering must carry. Asked early, it is a five-minute planning question that keeps a raise inside an exemption that actually fits. Asked late — after advertising has gone out, after a non-accredited friend has wired money into an accredited-only offering, after documents have been signed that describe a different pool — it becomes the question on which the exemption, and sometimes the investors’ right to unwind the purchase, depends.

So ask it first, ask it in writing, and ask it of everyone. Who is allowed to invest is not a detail of a lawful raise. In large part, it is the raise.

This article is education, not legal or investment advice. Whether a particular investor is accredited, and which exemption fits a particular offering, turn on the investor’s and the company’s specific facts and on the rules in force when the offering is made. Founders and investors should confirm their position with qualified securities counsel before any sale.

Jean-Francois Amyot is an independent journalist and author of The Art of War Remastered.

Jean-Francois Amyot
Jean-Francois Amyothttps://hollingerpost.com
Jean-Francois Amyot is an independent journalist and author. He writes on capital markets, cryptocurrency, blockchain, startups, financing and securities regulation (SEC, AMF, OSC), plus community stories on youth sport and helping young people stay in the game. Author of The Art of War Remastered and The World of Cryptocurrencies. Contact: jfamyot@gmail.com

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

Paper First: Term Sheets, Subscription Documents and Why a Handshake Is Not a Closing

By Jean-Francois Amyot Standfirst: A raise is not closed when...

Lionel Richie at the Encore: A Great Evening, All Night Long

There is a particular kind of performer who walks...

The Proper Steps to Raise Money Legally: Counsel, Structure, Disclosure, Then Investors

Standfirst: Most fundraising mistakes are made before the first...

SEC and CFTC Nominations: Four Picks, Two Committees, One Fast Clock

President Trump has sent the Senate four nominees to...