Standfirst: Most fundraising mistakes are made before the first investor is ever approached — in the order of operations. Founders who start with promotion and work backwards to paperwork inherit problems that are expensive to unwind. The lawful sequence runs the other way: counsel first, structure second, disclosure third, and investors last.
The mistake is usually sequence, not intent
Ask a founder how a raise begins and the answer is almost always a person: an uncle, a former colleague, a customer who believes in the product. Ask how it ends, months later, and the answer is often a document problem — a promise made in a text message that never made it into the subscription agreement, a shareholder who was never recorded properly, a round described one way in the pitch deck and another way in the filing.
Securities law is, in large part, a law about sequence. In the United States, an offer or sale of securities must either be registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or fit within an exemption from registration. That choice has to be made before the offering happens, because the exemption determines who may be approached, what may be said, what must be disclosed, and what must be filed. An exemption claimed after the fact, for an offering that was run a different way, is not a plan. It is an argument — and arguments with regulators are the most expensive way to finance a company.
The steps below are not a shortcut around that work. They are the work, in the order that makes each later step cheaper and safer than the one before it.
Step one: counsel before conversations
The first call in a lawful raise is not to an investor. It is to qualified securities counsel in every jurisdiction where the company is organised and where investors will be approached — in the United States, that means federal law and, depending on the path chosen, state law as well; in Canada, it means the provincial regulator in each province involved, such as Quebec’s Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) or the Ontario Securities Commission.
Counsel’s first job is the threshold question covered in an earlier article in this series: is what the company plans to sell a security? Shares plainly are. So, very often, are notes, convertible instruments, and arrangements in which people put in money expecting a return from someone else’s efforts. If the answer is yes — and founders should assume it is until counsel says otherwise — then every later conversation happens inside securities law, whether the founder uses that vocabulary or not.
Counsel also tests eligibility before enthusiasm builds. Not every company can use every exemption, and not every investor can be included in every offering. Finding that out in week one is a planning problem. Finding it out after money has been accepted is a rescission problem, in which investors may have the right to demand their money back.
Step two: choose the structure that fits the raise you actually have
Only once the threshold question is answered does it make sense to choose a route — and the route should be chosen for the raise the company actually has, not the raise it hopes to have.
A private placement under Regulation D is built for sales to a defined group, principally accredited investors, with disclosure and filing obligations that depend on the rule relied on. Regulation Crowdfunding — Reg CF — lets an eligible company raise up to $5 million in a 12-month period from the public, but only through a registered funding portal or broker-dealer, with a Form C filed with the SEC and limits on how much a non-accredited investor may invest. Regulation A goes larger in two tiers — up to $20 million under Tier 1 and up to $75 million under Tier 2 in a 12-month period — in exchange for an offering statement on Form 1-A that must be qualified by the SEC before sales, audited financial statements and ongoing reporting under Tier 2, and, under Tier 1, state review as well. A fully registered public offering sits at the top of that ladder, with the heaviest disclosure and reporting of all.
None of these routes is “the easy one.” Each trades reach for obligation: the wider the audience a founder wants, the more disclosure, filing and reporting the law asks for in return. Choosing the smallest route that honestly fits the amount, the audience and the company’s ability to keep reporting afterwards is not a lack of ambition. It is what makes the raise finishable.
Step three: build the disclosure before anyone is asked for money
Disclosure is the product an investor is actually buying into. Before a lawful offering opens, the company prepares the material an investor needs to decide: what the business does, what the money will be used for, what the risks are, who runs the company, what the financial statements show, and what rights the security being sold actually carries — dividends, votes, and what happens if the company is sold or wound up.
Two disciplines matter here. The first is completeness: a statement that is literally true can still mislead if it leaves out a material fact, and anti-fraud rules apply to exempt offerings just as they do to registered ones. The second is consistency: the pitch deck, the offering documents, the filings and anything said in meetings or online must tell the same story. Where they differ, the least favourable version is usually the one that gets read back later.
Financial disclosure deserves its own warning. The level required depends on the route — Reg CF ties the required financial statements to the size of the offering, and Reg A Tier 2 requires audited statements — but the direction is constant: the larger and more public the raise, the more independently checked the numbers must be. A company that cannot produce statements a reviewer can follow is not ready to ask the public for money, whatever exemption it prefers.
Step four: paper the raise properly
A handshake is not a closing. A lawful raise runs on documents that match the structure chosen in step two: a term sheet that states the real terms, subscription documents in which each investor confirms what they are buying and on what basis they qualify, and an up-to-date capitalisation table that records every share, option and convertible instrument already promised to anyone.
This is also where the mechanics are fixed in advance: how money moves, whether it is held in escrow until a minimum is reached where the route requires it, what identity and anti-money-laundering checks the intermediary or the company will run, and when an investor is actually a shareholder — at signing, at payment, or at closing. Ambiguity on any of those points is tolerable in a friendship. In a shareholder register, it compounds.
Step five: communicate inside the rules of the route
Promotion is where well-prepared raises most often go wrong, because promotion feels like marketing and is treated by the law as part of the offering. Each route has its own communications rules: what may be said before a filing, what may be said while an offering is open, and what must be included when it is said. “Testing the waters” is permitted in some routes, under conditions — it is not a general permission to build demand however a founder likes.
The standing rules are simpler than the route-by-route detail. Never promise returns, a listing, or liquidity that does not exist. Never let urgency substitute for disclosure. And if anyone is paid, in cash or in shares, to talk about the offering or the company’s securities, that compensation must be disclosed in the promotion itself. Undisclosed paid promotion is not aggressive marketing; it is one of the clearest lines in securities law, and it is crossed in private, in writing, long before a regulator reads it.
Step six: close cleanly — then keep the obligations
Closing is an administrative act, and it should feel like one: documents signed, funds received through the channel the route requires, securities issued, and the register updated so that the company’s own record of who owns what is complete the day the money arrives. Under Reg CF, securities generally cannot be resold for one year; other routes carry their own resale limits, and investors should be told theirs in plain language before they invest, not after.
And closing is not the end. Reg CF issuers owe annual reports. Reg A Tier 2 issuers owe ongoing periodic reporting. Private issuers owe their investors the honest updates they promised, and every issuer owes the market consistency: material information shared fairly, not whispered to the investors most likely to complain. The founders who treat the raise as the start of a reporting relationship, rather than the end of a sales campaign, are the ones whose second raise is easier than their first.
The sequence is the strategy
Counsel, structure, disclosure, paper, controlled communication, clean closing, continuing obligations. None of those steps requires a large company or a large budget to begin — they require only that a founder refuse to run them in reverse. Money raised in the right order can be defended to an investor, a bank, an acquirer and a regulator with the same file. Money raised in the wrong order has to be explained four different ways, and the explanations rarely match.
That, in the end, is the practical case for doing it properly: not fear of a regulator, but the value of a record that never has to be rewritten.
This article is education, not legal or investment advice. Which exemption fits a particular company, what disclosure it requires, and how its offering may be communicated turn on the company’s specific facts and on the rules in force when the offering is made. Founders should take their own structure to qualified securities counsel before approaching any investor.
Jean-Francois Amyot is an independent journalist and author of The Art of War Remastered.
